Custom software

Custom software or an off-the-shelf tool? How to decide with numbers

An off-the-shelf tool is quick and cheap to start with. Custom software adapts to your process. The decision is not ideological: it depends on how much it costs you to adapt to the tool.

Codigital Lab team2 min read

It is one of the questions we are asked most: should we build custom software, or is an off-the-shelf tool enough? The honest answer is that it depends, but not on taste. You can reason it through with numbers.

When an off-the-shelf tool is the best option

Standard tools (a CRM, a task manager, an invoicing program) have clear advantages:

  • You can use them from day one.
  • The upfront cost is low and the vendor handles maintenance.
  • They handle common processes well, the ones that are the same in every company.

If your process looks like most others and the tool covers it with minor tweaks, there is no point in building anything.

When it starts to get expensive

The problem appears when the company has to adapt to the tool, and not the other way round. Some signs:

  • Parallel spreadsheets to cover what the tool doesn’t do.
  • Data copied by hand from one system to another.
  • Process steps done outside the tool “because they don’t fit”.
  • Licences for features nobody uses.

Each of these has a cost in hours, errors and missed opportunities, even if it never shows up on an invoice.

Run the numbers

A simple way to compare both options over three to five years:

  1. Cost of the standard tool: licences + setup + hours the team loses on manual or duplicated tasks.
  2. Cost of custom software: development + yearly maintenance.
  3. Differential value: what you gain from a process that fits exactly how you work (fewer errors, more capacity, better service).

If the time lost each month is high and the process is part of what sets you apart, custom software usually pays off.

There is also a middle ground

You don’t always have to pick an extreme. Often the best solution is to keep the standard tool for what it does well and custom-build only the missing part, connected through integrations. That reduces both cost and risk.

Our recommendation

Before deciding, analyse the process and put numbers on the manual tasks. If you like, we can do it together: we help you compare options and tell you frankly when an off-the-shelf tool is enough.

// got you thinking?

Got a challenge? Let’s grab a coffee.

Tell us the problem and we will propose how to solve it, with a clear scope, timeline and budget.

Emailinfo@codigitalab.com
Phone+34 930 485 388
OfficesGirona · Barcelona